Erick Mutinda, the primary suspect in the murder of Multimedia University (MMU) student Sylvia Kemunto, was formally charged with murder in Nairobi. The accused appeared before Justice Diana Kavenza, where he pleaded not guilty to the charges.
Court Proceedings and Orders
During the court session, Justice Kavenza ordered a psychiatric evaluation of the accused to ascertain his mental fitness for trial. Mutinda was remanded at Nairobi Remand Prison and will undergo assessment at Mbagathi Hospital. The court deferred the issue of bail until the mental evaluation report and submissions from the Probation Officer are reviewed.
Mutinda will remain in custody for 30 days, with the case set for mention on May 29 to determine the hearing schedule and address the bail application.
Defence Arguments
The accused’s lawyer emphasized Mutinda’s cooperation with law enforcement, noting that he voluntarily surrendered to the authorities. The defence further argued that at 19 years old, the accused is a telecommunications student with no history of flight risk.
“Mutinda resides in Sultan Hamud, does not own a passport, and has no means to flee the jurisdiction,” the lawyer submitted, highlighting his client’s willingness to face justice.
The lawyer also pointed out the delay in conducting the psychiatric evaluation, urging the court to consider the presumption of mental fitness in criminal proceedings unless evidence proves otherwise.
Prosecution and Family Opposition
The State, supported by the victim’s family lawyers Danstan Omari and Sam Nyaberi, opposed any immediate bail application. The family expressed concerns over the possibility of Mutinda being released, citing the severity of the charges and their intent to contest any formal bail request.
Justice Kavenza directed both the prosecution and the victim’s legal representatives to file and serve affidavits within seven days to facilitate the next phase of the case.
Next Steps
The court’s decision on bail is expected during the next mention date, after the completion of the mental assessment and review of all filed affidavits.
The case has drawn significant public attention as Sylvia Kemunto’s family and friends seek justice, underscoring the gravity of gender-based violence and the safety of university students.
This development marks the beginning of a legal battle that will determine the accountability and future of the accused in connection with the tragic death of the MMU student.
